31/01/2025 11:35
From: rubina.kotak@utu.fi
To: petr.harmanec@matfyz.cuni.cz
aa53206-24 : Referee report

Article reference: aa53206-24
Title: Half a century of photometry at Hvar I. Overview and emission-line stars
Author(s): H. Bo, z , i'c , P. Harmanec, J. Horn, K. Juza, P. Koubsk'y, 
S. Kř'ıž, P. Mayer, P. Hadrava, D. Ru, z , djak , D. Sudar, S. , S , tefl, 
M. Wolf, P. Zasche, M. Brož, J. Havelka, J. Honsa, V. Kocourek, M. Tlamicha, 
F. Zď'arsk'y, A. Harmanec, J. Jon'ak, A. Oplistilov'a , I. Piantschitsch, 
I. Skoki'c, J. , Svrckov'a, K. Vitovsk'y, D. Vrsnak , M. Zummer

Dear Petr,
Your manuscript was submitted to a referee, Dr. Dietrich Baade, who recommends 
publication, but only following fairly significant revision 
(report link appended below). 

The referee is generally positive about the paper, but raises some valid 
concerns. Please take all points into account when revising the manuscript. 
When you have done so, upload the revised version to the A&A database using 
the following link: 
http://nestor.aanda.org/aa/user/article/aa53206-24

The editor-in-Chief and I have discussed the two major points raised by 
the referee regarding the content of the introduction and table 4. 
We agree with the referee that a more scientifically grounded introduction 
would be appropriate and that tabular information related to photoelectric 
photometry should be made available via e.g. zenodo, rather than in 
the main text of the article. The A&A office can provide more information 
on liaising with zenodo later in the process.

Do note that the nominal timescale for resubmission is within 3 months 
of receiving this first report, unless agreed otherwise with me. 

Please indicate all changes in either colour or boldface in the next version, 
and also include a point-by-point response to each of the referee's comments 
in your cover letter. However, please note that your source files should 
only include the "clean" revised version.  A separate pdf with the marked 
changes (bold or diff file) should be uploaded as an "optional file."

I look forward to receiving the revised version.

best wishes,
Rubina

Dr. Rubina Kotak
A&A Associate Editor 

=================
Referee report(s) on this version:


Report by referee 1:

Download attached file

Please see uploaded file.



=================

Before resubmitting your manuscript, please take the time to verify 
the following common language and formatting issues.

1) Please note the spelling convention (US or UK) of your paper and run 
a spell check specific to your preference (see the A&A language guide 
for authors, Sect. 2.1, for common spelling and punctuation differences 
between these two conventions).
2) Check that abbreviations and acronyms are introduced correctly 
(see Sect. 5.2.4).
3) Check your reference format (see Sect. 3.6.2).

The A&A language guide for authors is available at 
https://www.aanda.org/for-authors/language-editing/1-introduction.

For general information on publishing with A&A, please see 
the A&A author’s guide, available at
https://www.aanda.org/for-authors/author-information/paper-organization.
